I’ve actually read this book before and forgot until I actually started reading. Eric asked me if I was enjoying my book and I told him point blank that it wasn’t the sort of book you enjoyed.
And it’s not.
Amazon.com lists it as being for ages 9 to 12, but I think more sensitive 9 and 10 year olds might find the book to be just too much.
The Devil’s Arithmetic is the story of Hannah, a rather privileged Jewish girl who is “over” the whole passover thing. Her relatives, with concentration camp numbers tattooed on their forearms, seem distant and weird and she’s annoyed with the entire group of passover activities. Out of desperation (and maybe a little selfishness) Hannah dumps her into glass of wine into the cup for Elijah, her grandfather chooses her to ceremoniously open the front door to let him in and she is instantly transported to Poland in 1942, right before the Jews in that area were rounded up and sent off to the camps.
Hannah, known as Chaya in 1942, realizes quickly what their fate is to be and she attempts to warn people. Obviously they don’t listen because really who could have conceived of the idea of what was going to happen before it did? Hannah ends up crowded into a freight car where old women and babies and children die and then she enters the camp, frightened, but determined. There she meets the determined Ryvka who has decided that she will NOT die and does all she can to teach Hannah the ways of the camp.
Hannah returns, eventually, to present times with a new found understanding for the plight of her ancestors. She’s a changed person.
Who wouldn’t be.
The book was achingly difficult to read. I didn’t cry, but I literally felt myself recoiling as I read about the dead little girl, still sucking her thing, dead from the exhaustion and starvation and trauma. I know those things happened and they just…..mortify me. Horribly. The book reads quickly, for an adult, and I was finished with it in the space of an evening, between swimming and dinner and cuddle time, but the impression it makes is haunting and i have no doubt my mind won’t be returning to this book for some time.
